Hikvision and Dahua are the two most common brands that DIY IP camera enthusiasts flock to. But for those who are more budget conscious, there are other brands such as Lorex, Swann, Q-See, Amcrest, Reolink. These are also some of the IP camera brands that I get the most questions about.
In this second post of the IP camera brand comparison series, I am going to do an in-depth comparison of Hikvision vs. Lorex. In case you missed the first post in this comparison series, do go and check that out too.
First off, let’s dispense with the IP camera shaped elephant in the room. The thing with Lorex is that they simply do not sell standalone IP cameras – their cameras are intended to be used only with their own NVRs. In other words, you are not allowed to venture outside their ecosystem. This is totally against the ethos of openness and inter-operability that I champion here at VueVille. That’s why you won’t find us here at VueVille recommending Lorex IP cameras or NVRs.
However, for the sake of comparison and for satisfying your curiosity, its good to see how the Lorex (actually re-branded Dahua) cameras fare against the Hikvision IP cameras. I will look at the 4MP IP camera models as this is the most common resolution for newer IP cameras.
4MP IP Camera Duel – Hikvision DS-2CD2042WD-I vs. Lorex LNB4163
Here’s a summary in a nice and easy table:
|Feature||Hikvision DS-2CD2042WD-I||Lorex LNB4163|
|Sensor||1/3" 4 Megapixel Progressive Scan CMOS|
|Night Vision||Black & white night vision, IR cut filter with auto switch||Colour night vision, IR cut filter with auto switch|
|Minimum illumination||0.01 lux without IR and 0 lux with IR on||0.38 lux without IR and 0.28 lux with IR|
|Lens Type||Fixed type|
|Lens||4mm, 6mm @ F2.0, Angle of view: 83°(4mm) , 55.4°(6mm)||3.6mm @ F2.0, Angle of view: 83°|
|DC 12V power||Yes|
|Interfaces||Hikvision DS-2CD2042WD-I||Lorex LNB4163|
|Software features||Hikvision DS-2CD2042WD-I||Lorex LNB4163|
|Max Resolution||2688×1520 (4MP)||2688 x 1520 (4MP)|
|Max bitrate||16 Mbps||Unknown|
|3D Noise Reduction||Yes|
|Network storage||NAS (Supports NFS, SMB/CIFS), FTP, ANR||No|
|Alert events||Hikvision DS-2CD2042WD-I||Lorex LNB4163|
|Email alerts||Yes||No standalone operation, requires NVR|
|Push alerts||Yes||No standalone operation, requires NVR|
|Simple motion detection||Yes||No standalone operation, requires NVR|
|Line crossing detection||Yes||No|
|Abandoned/Missing object detection||No|
|Scene change detection||No|
Both the 4MP Lorex and Hikvision have the most common sensor in this class of IP camera, a 1/3″ progressive scan CMOS sensor.
The size of the sensor has a huge bearing on the low light ability of a camera, whether it be a camcorder or a security camera. The larger the sensor, the greater its ability to gather light and so do well in low light conditions. But as you cram in more and more pixels into the same size sensor, they get smaller and smaller, which adds noise. Noise is the bane of low light video and reduces the detail that you can get out of your video.
So while security camera manufacturers have pushed pixel count from 3MP to 4MP and beyond, they have not increased the sensor size. While the Hikvision has true 120dB Wide Dynamic Range (WDR) to help improve video quality, the Lorex doesn’t. This leaves the Lorex at somewhat of a disadvantage.
When it comes to minimum illumination required, again we see divergence. Hikvision can do a minimum illumination of 0.01 lux and 0 lux with IR on. When we compared the Hikvision to the actual Dahua, we noted that the Hikvision goes down to a lower f-stop to achieve this than the Dahua. Sadly the Lorex will struggle in low light as it cannot match the low light ability of the Hikvision or Dahua.back to menu ↑
The three most important software features that the Hikvision has are ONVIF support, the built-in NVR feature, and the advanced motion detection features that help reduce false alerts.
The Lorex being an IP camera that works only with their own products, has none of these features. But it does have one trick up its sleeve – full colour night vision. This is a very interesting feature and does set the Lorex brand apart. However be aware that the camera will switch back to black & white IR night vision below 1 lux to ‘ensure optimal low-light image quality’ as Lorex puts it.
So a near slam dunk for the Hikvision on the software front.
RTSP allows even non-ONVIF equipment (such as software) to access the security camera’s video stream. Examples are video players like the popular VLC player.
Motion Detection ability
Both cameras support basic motion detection but only the Hikvision supports advanced motion detection methods.
I can’t emphasize enough the importance of these advanced motion detection methods in reducing false motion alerts.back to menu ↑
Hikvision products come with a limited 3-Year Warranty at B&H Photo. Lorex has a 2 year warranty as standard, but can be extended to 3 years or 5 years for an extra fee.back to menu ↑
Was the outcome ever in doubt? Maybe it’s a bit unfair to compare a standalone IP camera like the Hikvision to the crippled-on-purpose Lorex that can only work with its own NVR. But that’s the choice Lorex made.
For IP cameras that are not designed to lock you into a particular brand, check out the other recommendations on our best outdoor IP cameras list.back to menu ↑